Book Pop Century for best overall value with Skyliner access, or Art of Animation only if you need family suites. Skip the All-Star resorts unless they’re significantly cheaper—bus-only transportation isn’t worth minor savings.
Book Pop Century Resort or Art of Animation Resort over the All-Star resorts. Both offer Skyliner access to EPCOT and Hollywood Studios, which alone justifies the small price difference. Pop Century delivers the best value for most guests, while Art of Animation is worth it only if you need a family suite.
The Two-Tier Reality of Value Resorts#
Disney’s Value Resorts split into two distinct categories: the Skyliner resorts (Pop Century and Art of Animation) and the bus-only All-Stars (Movies, Music, and Sports). This transportation difference creates a meaningful gap in convenience that overshadows nearly every other comparison factor.
Why Pop Century Wins for Most Guests
Pop Century Resort offers the strongest combination of location, transportation, and value. The Disney Skyliner gondola system connects you directly to EPCOT and Hollywood Studios without transfers, turning what would be 20-minute bus rides into 5-10 minute glides above the property. You’ll also reach the Skyliner hub at Caribbean Beach Resort, where you can transfer to the line serving Riviera Resort.
The resort’s theming celebrates decades from the 1950s through 1990s with oversized icons like bowling pins, yo-yos, and Rubik’s cubes. Rooms are standard Disney value size with two full beds or one king, sleeping up to four guests. The Everything Pop Shopping & Dining food court serves the same quality you’ll find at other value resorts—adequate but unremarkable, with grab-and-go options, pizza, pasta, and burgers.
When Art of Animation Justifies the Premium
Art of Animation Resort shares Pop Century’s Skyliner advantage but costs more. Book it only if you need a family suite. The resort’s Finding Nemo, Cars, and Lion King suites sleep up to six guests with a separate bedroom, two bathrooms, and a kitchenette. For families of five or six, one suite beats booking two standard rooms at Pop Century or the All-Stars.
If you’re booking a standard room in the Little Mermaid section, you’re paying extra for theming alone. The rooms are identical to Pop Century’s, and the Landscape of Flavors food court, while slightly more varied in stations, doesn’t deliver meaningfully better food. The Big Blue Pool is Disney’s largest resort pool and features underwater speakers, but this won’t matter if you’re spending full days in the parks.
The All-Stars: Only If Budget Is Absolute Priority
All-Star Movies, All-Star Music, and All-Star Sports are functionally identical. They’re the cheapest Disney-owned hotels, but you sacrifice Skyliner access and accept bus-only transportation to all four theme parks. Buses run on shared routes during slower periods, meaning you might stop at two or three All-Star resorts before reaching your park.
The theming differs—Movies features Disney film icons, Music showcases giant instruments and Broadway-style marquees, Sports displays oversized football helmets and surfboards—but room quality, food court offerings, and pool experiences are interchangeable. All three food courts serve the same rotation of standard theme park fare. None of the pools offer anything special beyond basic recreation.
All-Star Music does offer family suites similar to Art of Animation’s, sleeping up to six. If you need suite space and can’t afford Art of Animation, this works, but you’ll still deal with bus transportation.
Pool Rankings That Actually Matter
Art of Animation’s Big Blue Pool wins on size and theming, but Pop Century’s Hippy Dippy Pool with its bowling pin and flower power aesthetic functions just as well for cooling off after park days. The All-Star pools—Fantasia Pool (Movies), Calypso Pool (Music), and Surfboard Bay Pool (Sports)—are adequate but forgettable. You’re not choosing a value resort for its pool experience.
Food Court Reality Check
Don’t expect food court quality to influence your decision. Every value resort food court serves similar items at similar quality levels—acceptable for quick breakfast before Early Theme Park Entry or late-night pizza after fireworks, but nothing you’ll remember fondly. Art of Animation’s Landscape of Flavors offers slightly more variety with its station format, but you’re still choosing between pizza, burgers, pasta, and Asian-inspired bowls.
Who Should Book What
Book Pop Century if you’re a couple, solo traveler, or family of four who wants the best value-to-convenience ratio. The Skyliner access alone makes it the clear winner.
Book Art of Animation only if you need a family suite for five or six guests, or if your young children are obsessed with Finding Nemo, Cars, or Lion King theming.
Book an All-Star resort only if you’ve found a significantly cheaper rate than Pop Century and don’t mind bus-only transportation. Don’t waste time choosing between the three All-Stars—book whichever is cheapest.
ParkSwiz is not affiliated with The Walt Disney Company or its subsidiaries.
On this page