Table Service
Olivia's Cafe
disney-springs
Price range
$$
Moderate
Reservations
Easy — book a few days ahead
Type
Table Service
American, Key West casual
Olivia's Cafe channels Key West casual in the Old Key West resort, serving a comfort-forward menu of conch fritters, gumbo, and fish sandwiches in a laid-back island atmosphere that feels genuinely unhurried compared to the busier Disney dining scene.
Tips and reservation advice for Olivia's Cafe at disney-springs. Must try: Conch fritters.
Must try
Conch fritters; Key lime pie; grilled grouper sandwich; Bahamian seafood chowder
Insider Tip
Olivia's is a low-key, relaxed spot at Old Key West that's easy to overlook but genuinely charming. The Key lime pie is among the best on property. Because it's a resort restaurant that's off the beaten path, reservations are almost always available with minimal advance notice. A solid lunch choice if you're visiting Old Key West or just want to escape the crowds.
Best for
Last updated: May 2026
Questions about Olivia's Cafe?
Ask Swiz for tips on reservations, what to order, and the best strategy for your group.
Ask Swiz